Volume III • Issue 2• July 2005

The Sisterhood of the Travelling Pants
Review by Elizabeth Stanley

Over the span of my life I've become quite the expert on teeny-bopper novels. I read a lot of them when I was that age, and I still pick up a few from time to time. They make me feel accomplished. I can get through them in one sitting, usually, and because of that they don't have trouble holding my attention. Plus, they remind me that yep, it really sucked to be a teenager, and I'm really, really glad to be an adult now (even with the dishes and credit card debt). For some reason, summer makes me want to read teen novels more. Maybe because it's the biggest time of year when I miss being in school (when there's an absence of it).

This summer's candidate is The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants. The book is written by Ann Brashares and tells the story of the first summer that a group of childhood girlfriends spend apart from each other. I was interested in this book a) because they had made a movie out of it, so it must have some appeal; b) Gilmore Girls (my Tuesday night addiction) actress, Alexis Bledel is in the movie which made me want to see the movie and c) I like to try to read the novel before I see the movie.

So, I ordered the book from Amazon as is my custom and waited for it to arrive. And waited, as the first shipment of my book somehow got misdirected (Sort of ironic for the traveling pants book, no?). When it finally arrived I opened the package, set West Wing aside for another day and started into the book. I was pleasantly surprised.

I wasn't expecting a lot from this book. I expected some characters and enough plot to hold my attention through almost 300 pages, but the author accomplishes this and a bit more. She managed to create characters that the reader is interested in without making them overly adult or angst-ridden. The characters deal with problems facing typical teenagers a lot more gracefully than I ever did. Oh, and although the characters are confident--perhaps more confident than they should be as 15-year-olds--Brashares does a good job of showing how I remember thinking and doubting myself as a teenager.

However, there is the expected over-idealization of the teenage years. For example, these girls get to go to Greece and South Carolina and Soccer camp in Mexico. Most of my friends were lucky if they got to be a counselor at YMCA camp. We mostly stayed home and played cards. Then there’s occasions when the girls fight--they never fight like my friends and I did. They have spats over real issues that are quickly solved. I remember my friends at that age, fighting and hating each other for no reason. (Although maybe that's what teenagers who don't need medication for mental illnesses act like. You think I’m kidding? Most of my friends from high school are now on medication.) Or the fact that the girls all understand their own strengths and also their friends’ weaknesses. I think that's a stretch, even for people in their 20s. Most of my friends still don't understand their friends’ strengths and weaknesses, let alone their own.

The biggest thing that The Sisterhood accomplished was making me miss summertime and my best friend (who now lives 500 miles away). I miss the things that happen during the summer when school's out and you're still too young for a job and there are no other expectations. Like chasing the ice cream man, or playing Wiffle ball in the cul-de-sac or bike rides that include riding down hill with no hands or not having to come home until dark which was almost 10. Or just the feeling you get in June when the whole summer is there, ready for you, and holding the promise of experiences yet to come.

Something about summer always felt like the most real time of the year. The experiences were sharpened. Boys were cuter, and your parents and siblings were more annoying.  Maybe because the sun was brighter everything was more extreme.  The whole thing makes me want to become a teacher so I can spend the whole summer home reliving all those wonderful and not-so-wonderful experiences with my future children.

Oh, so, back to the book. My recommendation: If you can deal with teeny-bopper girl novels and like them, then I’d steer toward this. Plus, if you get hooked there are two more books to read (I always loved series books, made it easier to get over the depression of finishing a book you devoured too fast). It’s one of the better modern books of the genre.  Still no Madeline L'Engle, but better than The Babysitter's Club or The Princess Diaries and worth the five hours I put into the 300 pages.


Anti-Thoughts
Dustin Grovemiller
Confessions of a
Dingy Trooch

Bethany Shady
Currents
Laura Goodman
Gently With a Chainsaw
Leigh Sholler
No Action
Anthony Eldridge
Pure Lard
D.J. Kirkbride
Something About Nothing
Tadd Branum
Complaints From Moscow
Daria O. Fissoun
Rocket Science
Donny Seven
What Fresh Hell is This?
Kristin Gifford
Ninja Poetry Book Report
Remotely Controlled Spoiler Warning
One Final Note   

Your browser will occasionally need the Flash plug-in to properly display some contents of this site.

Articles will probably contain profanity, because we're all pretty rude. Please use discretion if you're easily offended.

All materials published in "the footnote" are the property of their respective authors (unless otherwise noted) and are published with their consent. All other material is Copyright 2005 by "the footnote."